91ԭ

Skip to content
Join our Newsletter

Lawrie McFarlane: Democrats risk stoking simmering working-class anger

Referring to the Bourbons when they returned to power, French statesman and diplomat Charles Talleyrand noted that “they had learned nothing and forgotten nothing.” America’s Democratic party appears determined to repeat that performance.
TC_237984_web_cc02a3e566ad47d9b8e29138efbc18e2-cc02a3e566ad47d9b8e29138efbc18e2-0.CPT637569257716357203.jpg
Migrants from Honduras wait in a Border Patrol truck after turning themselves in upon crossing the U.S.-Mexico border in La Joya, Texas. The Biden administration has agreed to let up to about 250 people a day into the U.S. at border crossings with Mexico to seek refuge, reinvigorating grievances about porous borders, writes Lawrie Mcfarlane. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull)

Referring to the Bourbons when they returned to power, French statesman and diplomat Charles Talleyrand noted that “they had learned nothing and forgotten nothing.”

America’s Democratic party appears determined to repeat that performance.

Driven by a determination to eradicate every last vestige of Donald Trump’s policies, they’ve set about recreating exactly the conditions that got Trump elected in the first place.

The border has been reopened to floods of “undocumented” immigrants. In April, 178,622 migrants entered the U.S. illegally, the highest number in 20 years.

And President Joe Biden has ordered that fines will no longer be imposed on immigrants who arrive illegally and are ordered by a judge to leave. The administration is even refunding fines paid during the Trump years.

Notably, it was the whole issue of porous borders and the large numbers of illegal immigrants entering the country that proved to be one of Trump’s most potent rallying points. Now that grievance is being reinvigorated.

The disastrous treaty with Iran, cancelled by Trump, is to be reopened, virtually ensuring that Iran becomes a nuclear state. That invites one of two calamities.

Either the region’s neighbouring countries, fearful of Iran’s attempts to cow and destabilize them, will themselves seek nuclear weapons. Or Israel will mount a military attack to wipe out the production facilities. Where does all that end?

Biden is also considering increasing the corporate tax rate from 21 per cent to 28 per cent, arguing that the burden will fall only on the wealthy (Trump had reduced it from 35 per cent to 21.)

But the Congressional Budget Office (a non-partisan body) calculates that middle- and low-income workers will bear 25 per cent of the burden.

Again, tax cuts were one of Trump’s foremost policies, arguably responsible, along with slashing red tape, for the lowest unemployment rates among Black and Hispanic families since records were first kept.

There’s plenty more of the same, and certainly some of Trump’s schemes were ill-advised or scrambled.

But you have to separate the policy from the man — something the Democrats appear unable to do. And the danger is that in failing to draw this distinction, they restoke the simmering anger among working-class Americans that handed Trump the White House.

Look at the numbers. Since the Second World War, the party holding the presidency has lost, on average, 26 House seats in midterm elections, and four Senate seats.

Currently, the Senate is tied 50-50 and the Democrats lost 13 seats in the House of Representatives during the 2020 election, giving them a majority of just six, with five seats vacant.

If next year’s midterms run true to course, the Democrats will surrender both centres of power.

A wiser program would be to steer a middle course, keeping in mind that electorally, the country is basically split in two, with little room for theatrics on either side.

But such were Trump’s divisive strategies that there is no room left for wisdom.

The Democrats have forgotten none of the insults to the republic they now lead. And likewise they have learned nothing about the rust-belt anger that brought those insults into being.